Bay Street Wire
Tech & BusinessOpinion

The 'Intelligence' Rebrand: Google's New Loophole for Your Private Data

Portrait of Naomi Frost
Naomi Frostcybersecurity & privacyOct 26AI
The 'Intelligence' Rebrand: Google's New Loophole for Your Private Data

AI-generated image · Bay Street Wire

By rebranding invasive ad-targeting as 'Personal Intelligence,' Google is dismantling the firewalls that once protected Gmail and Photos from its advertising engine.

For years, Google maintained a specific promise to its users: the sensitive contents of Gmail, Drive, and Photos were off-limits for ad personalization. It was a necessary firewall for anyone trusting the world's largest advertising company with their most private digital correspondence. Now, as Ars Technica first reported, Google is quietly dismantling that boundary.

On October 16, Google updated its privacy policy. The previous version contained a clear, definitive limit, stating, “We don’t show you personalized ads based on your content from Drive, Gmail, or Photos.” The new language is far more equivocal, opening a door for this sensitive data to inform advertising when shared across other Google services.

***

**Opinion:** *This is a classic corporate sleight-of-hand. Google isn't just updating a policy; it is attempting to normalize the erosion of our digital privacy by rebranding invasive targeting as 'intelligence.' By framing the exploitation of our personal data as a feature to improve AI accuracy, they are tricking users into opting into their own surveillance.*

***

The mechanism for this erosion is a feature released in early 2026 called "Personal Intelligence." This tool allows users to feed data from various apps into Google's AI products, such as the Gemini app and AI Mode search, to provide better context for AI-generated answers. While Gemini itself does not currently feature ads, AI Mode search does include sponsored content.

Google's updated policy acknowledges that data shared via Personal Intelligence could contribute to ad personalization. In a statement provided to Ars Technica, Google claims that ads will not be based “directly” on a user's Gmail inbox or Photos library, and that sensitive information will not be used to tailor ads. However, the company admits that ads will remain relevant to the user's query and the context of the AI's response.

This is a distinction without a difference. If a user interacts with AI Mode while Personal Intelligence is enabled, the AI generates summaries and insights derived from the user's personal data. Because those same insights inform the ad targeting in AI search, the personal data becomes a functional element of the advertising engine.

Google's defense, as relayed to Ars Technica by a company spokesperson, is that this does not change how data is handled with advertising partners or imply that Google is scanning entire inboxes to enhance profiles. Furthermore, the company asserts that Personal Intelligence is entirely opt-in.

Yet, the danger persists. Ars Technica notes that Google utilizes pop-ups and prompts to encourage users to enable these features, often without fully clarifying the privacy consequences. There is also the risk of model training; while Google says it doesn't use personal data for training, it does use model outputs. Because Personal Intelligence connects Gemini to various services, those outputs may contain personal information. Google claims it attempts to filter this content, but it offers no guarantee of success.

For those looking to close this loophole, the only solution is to disable Personal Intelligence. This can be done via Gemini settings or by navigating through Google account settings under Data & privacy, then Personalization settings, then Manage Personalized Recommendations in Search Services, and finally Connected Content Apps to disconnect Workspace and Google Photos.

Sources

More from Naomi Frost